Original, independent, thought leadership
CoW 11-14-2022-220221114 (002)

Small-cap sustainable index funds outperformed actively managed counterparts

0:00 / 0:00 ETF/Fund Name Tracking Index and ESG Integration Approach:  Exclusions and Inclusion Practices  Fund Size ($) Expense Ratio (%) iShares ESG Aware MSCI USA Small-Cap ETF  MSCI USA Small Cap Extended ESG Focus Index, derived from the MSCI USA Small Cap Index, consisting of companies that meet certain ESG criteria via exclusionary screening…

Share This Article:

The Bottom Line:  Recent outperformance of small-cap sustainable index funds versus actively managed sustainable counterparts influenced by their higher levels of exposure to value stocks.

0:00 / 0:00

ETF/Fund Name

Tracking Index and ESG Integration Approach:  Exclusions and Inclusion Practices 

Fund Size ($)

Expense Ratio (%)

iShares ESG Aware MSCI USA Small-Cap ETF 

MSCI USA Small Cap Extended ESG Focus Index, derived from the MSCI USA Small Cap Index, consisting of companies that meet certain ESG criteria via exclusionary screening based on MSCI determinations.  Inclusion is based achieving a higher allocation of companies with favorable ESG profiles through an optimization process.  

1,462.1

0.17

iShares® ESG Screened S&P Small-Cap ETF

S&P SmallCap 600 Sustainability Screened Index consisting of companies that meet certain ESG criteria via exclusionary screening, based on determinations made by Trucost, Sustainalytics and SAM ESG Research.  

36.1

0.12

Nuveen ESG Small-Cap ETF

TIAA ESG USA Small-Cap Index, derived from the MSCI USA Small Cap Index that meet certain ESG criteria via exclusionary screening based on MSCI determination.  Inclusion is based on highest ESG ranked companies.   

909.8

0.3

Praxis Small Cap Index A and I

S&P SmallCap 600 companies qualified as to companies aligned with Everence Capital Management’s Stewardship Investing core values:   Respecting the dignity and value of all people, building a world at peace and free from violence, demonstrating a concern for justice in a global society, exhibiting responsible management practices, supporting and involving communities, and practicing environmental stewardship. ESG factors may be optimized.  

147.1

1.12/0.43

SPDR S&P SmallCap 600 ESG ETF

S&P SmallCap 600 Sustainability Screened Index consisting of companies that meet certain ESG criteria via exclusionary screening, based on determinations made by Trucost, Sustainalytics and SAM ESG Research.  Worst ESG scoring companies are also excluded.  

2.6

0.12

Xtrackers S&P SmallCap 600 ESG ETF

S&P Small Cap 600 ESG Index. Similar to above criteria.

10.7

0.15

Fund assets and expense ratios source:  Morningstar Direct.  Otherwise, Sustainable Research and Analysis LLC.

Observations:

  • Sustainable small-cap index funds, including five ETFs and one mutual fund, outperformed actively managed sustainable small-cap funds in October and over the trailing twelve-month interval.  Sustainable small-cap index funds posted an average gain of 11.7% in October versus 9.4% registered by their actively managed counterparts and -14.3% year-to-date as compared to -17.9% for actively managed small-cap sustainable funds.  
  • A greater average exposure to small-cap value stocks in index funds versus actively managed funds was an important contributing factor to the performance differential.  Actively managed sustainable index funds had an average 14.8% exposure to value stocks versus 29.3%, on average, held in passively managed funds, almost twice as high.
  • Expense ratio differentials is also a factor.  The average expense ratio for actively managed sustainable small-cap funds is 1.08% versus 0.60 for sustainable small-cap index funds.  That number is significantly reduced to 0.17% when the high-priced Praxis Small Cap Index Fund A and I shares that charge 1.12% and 0.43% are excluded.  
  • Within the universe of sustainable small-cap index funds, performance variations are attributable to fund size, index construction methodologies and the criteria for qualifying and weighting securities based on their sustainability characteristics or ESG exclusionary screens that vary in accordance with the providers of ESG determinations.  Within the small-cap index funds segment, ESG determinations are provided by MSCI, S&P Dow Jones that relies on multiple sources as well as Everence Capital Management, Inc. for Praxis.   
  • Sustainable small cap index funds have attracted $2.6 billion in assets under management as of October 31, 2022, representing 35% of the segment’s total with $7.4 billion in assets as of the same date.
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
$99.99
PER YEAR

Premium Articles Access Priority Support 1 Fixed Price

Free Trial
30 Day

Access to All Data No Credit Card Required Cancel Any Time

9.99
Monthly

Access to Premium Articles Priority Support Save 25%


Sign up to free newsletters.


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: . You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

Research

Research and analysis to keep sustainable investors up to-date on a broad range of topics that include trends and developments in sustainable investing and sustainable finance, regulatory updates, performance results and considerations, investing through index funds and actively managed portfolios, asset allocation updates, expenses, ESG ratings and data, company and product news, green, social and sustainable bonds, green bond funds as well as reporting and disclosure practices, to name just a few.

A continuously updated Funds Directory is also available to investors.  This is intended to become a comprehensive listing of sustainable mutual funds, ETFs and other investment products along with a description of their sustainable investing approaches as set out in fund prospectuses and related regulatory filings.

Getting started

Many questions have surfaced in recent years regarding sustainable and ESG investing.  Here, investors and financial intermediaries will find materials that describe the various approaches to sustainable investing and their implementation.  While sustainable investing approaches vary and they have thus far defied universally accepted definitions, many practitioners agree that they fall into the following broad categories:  Values-based investing, investing via exclusions, impact investing, thematic investments and ESG integration.  In conjunction with each of these approaches, investors may also adopt various issuer engagement procedures and proxy voting practices.  That said, sustainable investing approaches will continue to evolve.

In addition to periodic updates regarding sustainable investing and how this form of investing is evolving, investors and financial intermediaries interested in implementing a sustainable investing approach will also find source materials that cover basic investing themes as well as asset allocation tactics.

Inesting ideas

Thoughts and ideas targeting sustainable investing strategies executed through various registered and non-registered sustainable investment funds and products such as mutual funds, Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs), Exchange Traded Notes (ETNs), closed-end funds, Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) and Unit Investment Trusts (UITs). Coverage extends to investment management firms as well as fund groups. 

Independent source for sustainable investment management company research, analysis, opinions and sustainable fund disclosure assessments