Original, independent, thought leadership
CoWOct 10-20221010

Performance advantage of ESG screened indices is narrowing

0:00 / 0:00

Share This Article:

The Bottom Line:  Long-term performance through September continues to support portfolios informed by or indexed to ESG screened international benchmarks, however, their advantage is narrowing.

0:00 / 0:00

Intermediate-to-long-term performance differential:  Selected ESG screened indices vs. conventional indices: Trailing 3, 5 and 10-years to September 30, 2022Notes of Explanation: The six MSCI ESG indices include the MSCI USA ESG Leaders Index consisting of large and mid-cap companies, MSCI USA Small Cap ESG Leaders Index, MSCI ACWI ex USA Leaders Index consisting of large and mid-cap companies in developed and developing countries, MSCI EAFE ESG Leaders Index consisting of large and mid-cap companies in developed markets.  MSCI Leaders indices are constructed to provide exposure to companies with high ESG scores relative to their sector peers.  Intermediate term covers 3 and 5 years.  Long-term=10 years.  Data source:  MSCI

Observations:

  • The outperformance of ESG screened indices, a consideration in promoting the alpha generating properties of ESG versus conventional investing in 2021, continued to narrow in September.  This observation is based on the tracking of six selected MSCI ESG Leaders indices and their performance, including two US stock indices, three international and one fixed income index.    
  • The reality of higher interest rates and high inflation fueled by high employment and strong demand triggered a decline of 9.27% in the MSCI USA Index (large and mid-cap companies) in September while the Bloomberg Aggregate US Bond Index gave up 4.32%.  All but one industry sector posted negative results.  Against this backdrop, three of five selected US and international ESG screened equity indices comprised of companies with high ESG scores relative to sector peers and one bond fund index lagged behind their conventional counterparts, for a total of four underperforming indices of six.  This is the third month in a row during which four or more of the same six indices trailed, and the sixth month so far in 2022. 
  • The US-oriented benchmarks, the MSCI USA ESG Leaders Index and the MSCI USA Small Cap ESG Leaders Index, exceeded the total return performance of their conventional counterparts in September by 31 basis points (bps) and 92 bps, respectively.  Both indices lagged last month but retain a performance advantage over the 1-year term.  That said, the two indices delivered mixed results in the intermediate 3-year and 5-year time periods while falling behind over the ten- year time horizon to September 30, 2022. 
  • The three international indices, including the MSCI ACWI ex USA ESG Leaders Index, the MSCI Emerging Markets ESG Leaders Index and the MSCI EAFE ESG Leaders Index, fell behind their conventional counterparts in September by 65 bps, 97 bps and 53 bps, respectively.  The indices now also trail over the 1-year and 3-year time periods but continue to lead with narrower margins over 5-years and 10-years.
  • As for fixed income, the Bloomberg MSCI ESG Focus Aggregate Bond Index posted the sharpest monthly decline so far this year, giving up -4.34% versus -4.32% for the Bloomberg US Aggregate Bond Index.  It’s also off by 2 bps over the previous twelve-month interval but leads by 5 bps over the trailing 3-years.  The index was launched less than five years ago.
  • While long-term results continue to support ESG screened international benchmarks, the leads posted by the international indices, in particular, relative to conventional benchmarks have been shrinking by a minimum of 50% over the 10-year and 5-year terms since January 2021.
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
$99.99
PER YEAR

Premium Articles Access Priority Support 1 Fixed Price

Free Trial
30 Day

Access to All Data No Credit Card Required Cancel Any Time

9.99
Monthly

Access to Premium Articles Priority Support Save 25%


Sign up to free newsletters.


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: . You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

Research

Research and analysis to keep sustainable investors up to-date on a broad range of topics that include trends and developments in sustainable investing and sustainable finance, regulatory updates, performance results and considerations, investing through index funds and actively managed portfolios, asset allocation updates, expenses, ESG ratings and data, company and product news, green, social and sustainable bonds, green bond funds as well as reporting and disclosure practices, to name just a few.

A continuously updated Funds Directory is also available to investors.  This is intended to become a comprehensive listing of sustainable mutual funds, ETFs and other investment products along with a description of their sustainable investing approaches as set out in fund prospectuses and related regulatory filings.

Getting started

Many questions have surfaced in recent years regarding sustainable and ESG investing.  Here, investors and financial intermediaries will find materials that describe the various approaches to sustainable investing and their implementation.  While sustainable investing approaches vary and they have thus far defied universally accepted definitions, many practitioners agree that they fall into the following broad categories:  Values-based investing, investing via exclusions, impact investing, thematic investments and ESG integration.  In conjunction with each of these approaches, investors may also adopt various issuer engagement procedures and proxy voting practices.  That said, sustainable investing approaches will continue to evolve.

In addition to periodic updates regarding sustainable investing and how this form of investing is evolving, investors and financial intermediaries interested in implementing a sustainable investing approach will also find source materials that cover basic investing themes as well as asset allocation tactics.

Inesting ideas

Thoughts and ideas targeting sustainable investing strategies executed through various registered and non-registered sustainable investment funds and products such as mutual funds, Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs), Exchange Traded Notes (ETNs), closed-end funds, Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) and Unit Investment Trusts (UITs). Coverage extends to investment management firms as well as fund groups. 

Independent source for sustainable investment management company research, analysis, opinions and sustainable fund disclosure assessments