Original, independent, thought leadership
Bar graph moving up. Positive bar chart in blue, rising line in orange. Business, financial figures, revenue, cash flow, analyzing, growth, stock market and exchange. Abstract financial concept.

Actively managed sustainable ETFs gaining some traction

Performance of top 10 actively managed sustainable ETFs relative to designated market index:  Trailing 12-months to July 31, 2023Notes of Explanation:  *Dimensional US Sustainability Core 1 ETF, Dimensional International Sustainability Core 1 ETF and Putnam ESG Core Bond ETF have not been operating for a full year.  Prior to 7/14/2023, the JPMorgan Sustainable Municipal ETF…

Share This Article:

The bottom line:  Actively managed conventional as well as sustainable ETFs have been gaining some traction, but investors should carefully consider their alternative investing options.

Performance of top 10 actively managed sustainable ETFs relative to designated market index:  Trailing 12-months to July 31, 2023Notes of Explanation:  *Dimensional US Sustainability Core 1 ETF, Dimensional International Sustainability Core 1 ETF and Putnam ESG Core Bond ETF have not been operating for a full year.  Prior to 7/14/2023, the JPMorgan Sustainable Municipal ETF operated as an open-end mutual fund.  Total return performance based on NAV. Designated market index as disclosed in fund’s prospectus or summary prospectus.  Sources:  Morningstar Direct and Sustainable Research and Analysis.

Observations:

  • An article published last week in the Wall Street Journal entitled Index-Tracking ETFs Were All the Rage, Until Now sets forth that “the titans of the ETF industry are facing competition in the battle for new money.”  Firms like BlackRock, Vanguard and State Street that dominate the market for exchange-traded passively managed funds are facing competition from new players like JPMorgan Asset Management and Dimensional Fund Advisors that have entered the market by focusing on actively managed ETFs.  Another source, Bloomberg Intelligence, reported that the segment of actively managed ETFs drew 23% of total ETF inflows this year, despite holding just 4% of the industry’s assets in January.
  • Actively managed ETFs have also gained some traction in the sustainable investing sphere.  While new listings of actively managed sustainable ETFs through the end of July trailed passively managed ETF launches this year by four funds, last year new listings of actively managed ETFs dominated by a ratio of 2.2 to 1 across the universe of 61 ETF new listings in 2022.  That said, the net assets of actively managed sustainable ETFs expanded by $3.2 billion to reach $8.6 billion year-to-date, posting a 60% net gain while passively managed sustainable ETFs netted $3.8 billion, or just 4%, even as sustainable index funds account for 94% of the segment’s assets under management.
  • These developments are somewhat surprising given the accepted view that most actively managed funds, both equity funds and fixed income funds, tend to underperform the market, in part, due to higher expense ratios.  This would also apply to sustainable funds, although funds in this category are still relatively new and their performance track record is limited.  This is either because sustainable ETFs have only recently been launched or their strategies have been rebranded in recent years to reflect that adoption of a sustainable investing approach.
  • According to the latest data compiled by S&P’s Indices Versus Active (SPIVA) report [1] that compares the performances of actively managed funds to their appropriate benchmarks, the vast majority of actively managed funds underperform, with margins of underperformance widening over long periods of 10 years or more. The chances are better for the outperformance in investment-grade intermediate funds but here too, levels of underperformance are high.  Even in a year of declining markets, like 2022, when active management skills can be more valuable, S&P’s data shows that 51% of active managers underperformed in the US large-cap equity sphere and 79% underperformed in the investment-grade intermediate bond fund area.
  • An evaluation of the top 10 sustainable actively managed ETFs as of July 31st shows that only six funds have been in operation for a full 12-months and of these funds, only two funds, or 33%, outperformed their designated benchmarks.  The two outperforming funds were both bond funds.  The top 10 funds manage $4.8 billion in net assets and account for 55% of the actively managed sustainable funds segment.
  • Given the historical performance record of active managers, the limited track record of sustainable fund managers as well as higher expense ratios [2], on average, sustainable investors should carefully consider whether they may be better served by investing in an equivalent or similar index fund offering; and consider actively managed funds in cases where passively managed options are not available and exposure to the particular active investment strategy is highly desirable.
 
[1]S&P Down Jones:  SPIVA U.S. Year-End 2022, S&P Dow Jones Indices.
[2] Average expense ratio of actively managed sustainable ETFs is 52 basis points as compared to 35 basis points for their passively managed counterparts, as of July 31, 2023.   
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
$99.99
PER YEAR

Premium Articles Access Priority Support 1 Fixed Price

Free Trial
30 Day

Access to All Data No Credit Card Required Cancel Any Time

9.99
Monthly

Access to Premium Articles Priority Support Save 25%


Sign up to free newsletters.


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: . You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

Research

Research and analysis to keep sustainable investors up to-date on a broad range of topics that include trends and developments in sustainable investing and sustainable finance, regulatory updates, performance results and considerations, investing through index funds and actively managed portfolios, asset allocation updates, expenses, ESG ratings and data, company and product news, green, social and sustainable bonds, green bond funds as well as reporting and disclosure practices, to name just a few.

A continuously updated Funds Directory is also available to investors.  This is intended to become a comprehensive listing of sustainable mutual funds, ETFs and other investment products along with a description of their sustainable investing approaches as set out in fund prospectuses and related regulatory filings.

Getting started

Many questions have surfaced in recent years regarding sustainable and ESG investing.  Here, investors and financial intermediaries will find materials that describe the various approaches to sustainable investing and their implementation.  While sustainable investing approaches vary and they have thus far defied universally accepted definitions, many practitioners agree that they fall into the following broad categories:  Values-based investing, investing via exclusions, impact investing, thematic investments and ESG integration.  In conjunction with each of these approaches, investors may also adopt various issuer engagement procedures and proxy voting practices.  That said, sustainable investing approaches will continue to evolve.

In addition to periodic updates regarding sustainable investing and how this form of investing is evolving, investors and financial intermediaries interested in implementing a sustainable investing approach will also find source materials that cover basic investing themes as well as asset allocation tactics.

Inesting ideas

Thoughts and ideas targeting sustainable investing strategies executed through various registered and non-registered sustainable investment funds and products such as mutual funds, Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs), Exchange Traded Notes (ETNs), closed-end funds, Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) and Unit Investment Trusts (UITs). Coverage extends to investment management firms as well as fund groups. 

Independent source for sustainable investment management company research, analysis, opinions and sustainable fund disclosure assessments